Call or text (732) 301-6802 Virtually across New Jersey and in person in Metuchen, NJ Client portal
Home / Blog / Why Can't I Talk About How I Feel?

From the Therapy Aligned blog

Why Can't I Talk About How I Feel?

Clinically reviewed by Jacob Ventricelli, LAC, NCC on

A frosted window pane with a clear patch showing a garden beyond

Key takeaways

  • Finding the words is something people learn, often in small steps, and therapy is one place to practice.
  • Treat "stressed" and "fine" as first drafts, and ask what sits under them.
  • You do not need the right vocabulary to start.
In this article

If the honest answer to "How are you?" won't come out, there is usually a history behind that. Many men grew up where hard feelings were handled by pushing through, fixing the problem or staying busy, and putting them into words was rarely practiced. Research links sticking closely to traditional ideas about masculinity with how men express depression and whether they look for help. Finding the words is something people learn, often in small steps, and therapy is one place to practice.

Maybe your partner says you shut down in arguments. Maybe a hard week leaves you heavy, and the only words that come are "fine" or "tired." Or the one feeling that comes out easily is anger.

Where does the silence come from?

In an influential article in American Psychologist, psychologists Michael Addis and James Mahalik argued that whether men seek help depends on context: on what they learned about being a man, and on the situation they are in when they need help.

The lessons are often familiar. Handle it yourself. Don't burden anyone. Keep it together for the family. Feelings slow you down. Some of those rules may have served you on a job site, in the military or in a hard home. They tend to cost more in a marriage, a friendship or a doctor's office, where someone needs to know what is going on inside you.

Family and culture shape this too. In some homes, talking about feelings outside the family is its own kind of disloyalty, and that is worth respecting as you decide what to share and with whom.

Why does it come out as anger or numbness?

The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) lists symptoms that may be more common in men than in women, including anger, irritability or aggressiveness; misuse of alcohol or drugs; high-risk activities; and aches, headaches or digestive problems without a clear cause.

A 2016 systematic review of 37 studies by Zac Seidler and colleagues found that conforming to traditional masculine norms affected men with depression in three ways: their symptoms and how they expressed them, their attitudes toward and use of help, and how they managed their symptoms.

So if irritability, a few more drinks than you planned or a stomach that won't settle is the main signal you notice, other feelings may be showing up there. A doctor or therapist can help sort out what is going on.

Does putting it into words help?

In a brain-imaging study, Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that labeling the emotion in a picture with a word reduced the response of the amygdala, a brain area involved in emotional reactions, to negative images. It is a lab finding about the brain, and it gives a reason to try naming what you feel instead of only carrying it.

How do you find the first words?

Start smaller than a conversation.

  1. Notice where it sits. A tight jaw, a heavy chest, a knot in your stomach.
  2. Pick from a short list: angry, sad, worried, ashamed, lonely, relieved. The closest word is good enough.
  3. Treat "stressed" and "fine" as first drafts, and ask what sits under them.
  4. Give it a number from 1 to 10. Numbers can be easier to say than words.
  5. Say one true sentence to one person, such as "This week has worn me down more than I've let on."

Some people find it easier to talk side by side, on a walk or in the car, than face to face. Our post on emotional regulation as knowing what you feel goes further into naming feelings.

What if therapy sounds like the last thing you want?

You do not need the right vocabulary to start. A therapist can begin with something concrete: sleep, work, a fight at home, drinking, a decision you are stuck on. "I don't know" and "I'm not good at this" are honest first answers, and a good therapist will work with them. Nobody will push you to tell everything in the first hour, and sessions can be practical.

Therapy for men's mental health in New Jersey describes how we work with men on stress, anger, relationships and low mood. If you want to know what happens in the room, read what to actually expect in a first therapy session.

Men in the United States die by suicide at a much higher rate than women. A 2026 data brief from the National Center for Health Statistics, part of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, found that in 2024 the suicide rate for men in the United States, adjusted for age, was 22.3 per 100,000, compared with 5.6 for women. That year 38,977 men died by suicide, and from 2014 to 2024 the rate for men stayed about 3 to 4 times the rate for women. If you are thinking about ending your life, call or text 988 (Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) now, or call 911 in an emergency.

Common questions

Why is it harder for some men to talk about feelings?

Often because of what they learned about being a man and the settings they are in. Research ties close adherence to traditional masculine norms to how men express depression and whether they seek help.

Can anger be a sign of depression in men?

It can. NIMH lists anger, irritability or aggressiveness among symptoms that may be more common in men. If anger is new or growing, raise it with a doctor or therapist.

What if I don't know what I feel?

Start with where you feel it in your body, then pick the closest word from a short list. Close is good enough at the start.

Do I have to talk about my childhood in therapy?

No. You choose what to bring. Many people start with something current, such as work, sleep or a relationship, and decide later whether the past is worth looking at.

What if talking face to face is the hard part?

Some people find it easier to talk side by side, on a walk or in the car, than face to face. You can also start smaller than a conversation: notice where the feeling sits in your body, pick the closest word from a short list, or give it a number from 1 to 10.

How to start

You can start a first session with "I'm not sure what to say," and go from there. Therapy Aligned offers sessions in person in Metuchen, NJ and telehealth across New Jersey. Clients must be located in New Jersey at the time of the session. You can use our intake form to request a free consultation.

Sources

Next step: read about Men's Mental Health at Therapy Aligned, and see what insurance we accept and self-pay.

As a group practice, Therapy Aligned is in-network with Horizon BCBS, Aetna, Cigna, United Healthcare/Optum, and Oscar.

Clinicians who can support you with this

Our Psychotherapist Fellows have individual supervision every week, and Andrew H. Kim, Chandni Patel, or both are involved in each fellow's cases. How supervision works

More from the blog

This article shares general information and is not a substitute for therapy.

Take the next step

Start an inquiry

Therapy Aligned is not a crisis service. If you are in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), or call 911 in an emergency.

Blog